play_arrow
Y WORLD Radio Station Y WORLD RADIO

The applicants challenging Home Affairs’ detention practices have told the Johannesburg High Court that the department cannot rely on its administrative shortcomings to justify keeping prospective asylum seekers in prolonged detention.
They argue that Home Affairs’ limited capacity to process asylum applications cannot come at the expense of people’s constitutional right to freedom.
The arguments, heard on Tuesday, form part of a landmark legal challenge involving 33 urgent applications concerning the detention of prospective asylum seekers.
Representing five Ethiopian nationals, legal representative Thato Madubanye, told the full bench that his clients were only released after court intervention.
He argued that expressing an intention to seek asylum should give foreign nationals access to the asylum process, rather than leave them in prolonged detention.
play_arrow
Home Affairs cannot use capacity constraints to justify prolonged detention, asylum seekers tell court Nonhlanhla Harris
The applicants are challenging Home Affairs’ proposal to detain prospective asylum seekers for up to 14 days while their applications are processed.
The department has cited capacity and logistical constraints at Refugee Reception Offices as reasons for requiring additional time.
However, civil society organisations KAAX and Scalabrini argue that detention does little to address the underlying challenges facing the asylum system, including long queues and limited processing capacity.
Representing the organisations, advocate David Simons says detaining prospective asylum seekers simply moves them to the front of an already overwhelmed system without resolving the department’s capacity problems.
play_arrow
Home Affairs cannot use capacity constraints to justify prolonged detention, asylum seekers tell court Nonhlanhla Harris
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), which is participating in the proceedings as a friend of the court, has argued that expressing an intention to seek asylum should not automatically result in immediate release.
NPA representative, William Mokhari, says immigration officers should retain discretion to detain individuals for up to 48 hours while facilitating access to the asylum process.
He argues that any detention beyond that period should require authorisation from a judicial officer, who must consider the circumstances of each case.
play_arrow
Home Affairs cannot use capacity constraints to justify prolonged detention, asylum seekers tell court Nonhlanhla Harris
Home Affairs maintains that a limited period of detention is necessary to facilitate access to the asylum process and prevent individuals from disappearing before completing their applications.
The court is also considering the implications of previous Constitutional Court judgments on the rights of undocumented foreign nationals who express an intention to seek asylum, including those who entered the country illegally.
The full bench is expected to consider the competing legal arguments before delivering a ruling that could clarify the limits of detention and the state’s obligations towards prospective asylum seekers.
Written by: Lebohang Ndashe
Written by: Nonhlanhla Harris
asylum applications asylum seekers constitutional rights detention Home Affairs Johannesburg High Court National Prosecuting Authority Refugee Reception Offices undocumented foreign nationals
8:00 pm - 10:00 pm
10:00 pm - 12:00 am
12:00 am - 5:00 am
5:00 am - 9:00 am
9:00 am - 12:00 pm